“F#ck you, Laine! I’m tired of your $hit!”

That's the response this week by Oregon trawl rep and NPFMC advisor Heather Mann when pressed about "midwater" trawl gear fishing hard on bottom.

by | March 11, 2026

For several years, I’ve been writing about the fact that midwater trawl gear is actually fishing hard on bottom much of the time based on reports by the North Pacific Fishery Management Council’s scientific staff. It is the first time the amount of bottom contact by mid-water (pelagic) trawl gear has been put in writing.

The Council also learned the current federal pelagic trawl gear definition had not been updated since 1993.

While the trawl sector constantly boasts about “the science” and “transparency” in their documents, marketing and media, no trawl rep will respond to questions about the findings that pelagic nets contact the seafloor on average from 40% to 80% of the time, with rates up to 100% on catcher/processors (factory trawlers).

This week I again questioned Heather Mann, mouthpiece for the Oregon-based Midwater Trawlers Cooperative, who also serves on the NPFMC’s Advisory Panel. Her response? “Fuck you, Laine! I’m tired of your shit.”

I guess the “shit” Mann is referring to is the writing I’ve done on the topic of pelagic gear in recent years. Below is a sampler:

From the AK Marine Conservation Council

A February 2023 report by the Alaska Marine Conservation Council outlines the findings in a North Pacific Council report from last April revealed for the first time that pelagic, or mid-water, trawl nets contact the seafloor on average from 40% to 80% of the time, with rates up to 100% on factory ships, also called catcher/processors.

Some background: When the 2021 red king crab fishery was cancelled for the first time in 25 years, the NPFMC tasked its staff to prepare a discussion paper. Among the topics was to “Provide the best available information on bottom contact by pelagic (mid-water) trawl gear and the impact it may have on Bristol Bay red king crab stocks (BBRKC).”

The paper also revealed that the federal government applies its rules differently to on-bottom (non-pelagic) and pelagic (mid-water) gears.    

But former NPFMC chair, Stephanie Madsen, admitted that it is an uncomfortable fact that many have known about (and brushed under the rug) for decades.

“It is an estimate” and “not proven.”
“It has been know all along by many.”

Stephanie Madsen, former director of Seattle-based At-sea Processors Association and former NPFMC chair at a Nov. 7, 2022 bycatch task force meeting

“We don’t really know enough about how our gear functions.”

Julie Bonney, formerly of AK Groundfish Data Bank (although the AK pollock fishery has been going on since the 1990’s)

Twisting legal definitions also played out with NOAA and the NPFMC when it came to protecting Alaska crab.

The NPFMC and NOAA denied an emergency petition to prevent fishing in “savings zones” for six months to protect mating and molting king crab because it didn’t fit the definition of “emergency action.” While the zones are off-limits to bottom trawl gear, it’s open season for “pelagic” trawls.

“I agree most certainly that this is an emergency. It just doesn’t merit the criteria of the emergency action.”   

ANDY MEZIROW, FORMER NPFMC MEMBER, December 2022

From NOAA’s Office of Law Enforcement (OLE) —

A brief OLE report provides details of patrols and actions throughout Alaska waters from October 2022 to March 2023.

NOAA agents, in partnership with the Coast Guard and Alaska Wildlife Troopers, initiated Operation Bottom Trawl “to inspect trawl vessels carrying Non Pelagic Trawl (NPT) gear in NPT restricted areas” in the Gulf of Alaska and Bering Sea/Aleutian Islands.

“OLE reviewed 802 trips demonstrating carriage and or use of trawl gear in waters that prohibit use or possession of NPT gear,” the report says.

702 were in the Bering Sea red king crab savings area and 100 were in the Gulf of Alaska Slope Habitat Conservation Area and at Marmot Island near Kodiak, a “no transit zone” to protect endangered sea lions.

The trawlers found using non-pelagic trawls in the red king crab savings area had no enforcement action taken against them, nor did trawlers using non-pelagic trawls in the Gulf of Alaska protected areas.

The reason why, according to the OLE report, is that “national definitions include the codend within the definition of the trawl net, it’s unclear whether the codend was intended to be regulated within the Alaska fisheries”.

and —

“While pelagic trawl gear does contact the bottom, it is not defined as Bottom Contact Gear and it is not restricted in Habitat Conservation and Protection Areas.”

An example of pollock “midwater” trawl takes over 5 years: 345 metric tons of sea stars (760,000 pounds)

This chart is from the certifying group for the Marine Stewardship Council — all totals are in metric tons. (Note halibut bycatch of nearly 1.3 million pounds).

Council discussion continues

At its upcoming June 1-9 meeting in Vancouver, WA – far away from Alaskans who are directly impacted by its decisions and at the start of Alaska’s salmon season – the trawl top-heavy Council says it “intends to use the updated bottom contact estimates in the Fishing Effects model and gear research to develop options to revise the performance standard for pelagic trawl gear operations, based on previously stated Council objectives and available information.”

That means “discussions” will occur for several more years – while “midwater” trawl gear continues fishing hard on bottom throughout Alaska waters.

All of the chaos surrounding midwater trawl is proof that it’s past time for the sector to start advocating for reform within its OWN ranks, so that it doesn’t just get banned outright.

“The Council needs to talk less about what midwater trawl IS and more about what it DOES. That’s very different. There is much anger and confusion and a huge disconnect with the public on how this is being addressed.”

linda kozak, fishery consultant, former chair of the AK bycatch council

“The term pelagic has become a loophole, not a gear type. A branding gimmick that lets the fleet trawl in closed areas, avoid habitat protections, and claim they’re doing less harm than they are. It’s a lie, and this doc shows the council and NMFS know it. Classify all trawl as a single gear type and outlaw its use in existing habitat conservation and protection areas and in any other areas needed to preserve stocks and habitat.”

Sarah Mayer comment to the NPFMC

SEE COMMENTS ON PELAGIC TRAWL HERE from the June 2025 NPFMC meeting

Advertisement

You May Also Like

About Laine

Laine Welch has covered the Alaska fish beat for print and radio since 1988. She also has worked “behind the counter” at retail and wholesale seafood companies in Kodiak and on Cape Cod.

Pin It on Pinterest